8 advantages and disadvantages of forming a corporation for your business

Deciding to incorporate your business is a pivotal step that can shape its future trajectory. There are distinct advantages of corporation, from robust legal protections and significant tax benefits to enhanced credibility among shareholders and the wider market.

But transitioning to an incorporated business entity also brings its own set of challenges, and that merits careful consideration. To make an informed decision, you need to understand different corporation types and weigh all of their pros and cons. That’s where this article comes in; below, we’ll explore the key benefits and drawbacks of forming a corporation, providing you with the insights needed to determine if incorporation aligns with your business goals.

What is a corporation?

A corporation is a distinct legal entity separate from its owners, which means that the corporation itself can enter into contracts, own assets, incur debt, and pay taxes, much like an individual. The owners of a corporation are known as shareholders, who hold shares of stock representing their ownership stakes. Shareholders can earn profits through stock appreciation and dividends, which are distributions of the company's earnings.

One of the key features of a corporation is the transferability of ownership. Shares of stock can be bought and sold, allowing shareholders to easily transfer their interests without disrupting the corporate structure. This flexibility not only facilitates investment but also makes it easier for corporations to raise capital.

Corporations are governed by a board of directors, elected by the shareholders. While the shareholders are the ultimate owners, the board of directors is responsible for making major decisions and overseeing the corporation's strategic direction. This governance structure ensures that the corporation operates smoothly and aligns with the interests of its shareholders, even when ownership changes.

Forming a corporation can involve navigating various legal requirements depending on the jurisdiction, such as filing articles of incorporation with the appropriate state or secretary of state office. The process can be complex and time-consuming, often taking several months to complete. Despite the complexity, incorporating provides significant legal protections, because owners of a corporation are not personally liable for the corporation's debt. This limited liability is a major advantage, shielding personal assets from business-related risks.

In short, a corporation offers a robust business structure that combines legal protections, ease of transferring ownership, and opportunities for growth through stock issuance and dividends. However, the process of incorporating requires careful consideration of the legal obligations and the commitment to maintaining compliance with ongoing regulatory requirements.

Types of corporations

Deciding to incorporate your business is just the beginning. The next step is selecting the type of corporation that best aligns with your business goals and operational needs. Each corporate structure offers unique advantages and challenges, impacting everything from ownership to tax obligations. Below, we’ll explore the most common types of corporations to help you make an informed decision.

C Corporation (C-corp)

A C Corporation (C-corp) is a legal entity that allows for an unlimited number of shareholders, providing flexibility in ownership. C-corps offer limited liability protection, meaning owners are not personally liable for the corporation’s debts or legal obligations. Under this business structure, the company raises capital by selling stocks, making it easier to attract shareholders and invest in growth opportunities.

However, C-corps face double taxation. The corporation itself pays taxes on its income, and shareholders also pay taxes on dividends they receive. Despite this, the ability to reinvest profits back into the company without immediate tax consequences can be a significant advantage for businesses with plans to expand rapidly.

S Corporation (S-corp)

An S Corporation (S-corp) is designed for smaller businesses with up to 100 shareholders, all of whom must be U.S. citizens or residents. Unlike C-corps, S-corps are pass-through entities, meaning the corporation’s income, credits, losses, and deductions flow directly to the shareholders’ personal tax returns. This structure eliminates double taxation, as the corporation itself does not pay taxes on its income.

S-corps also provide limited liability protection—owners are not personally liable for business debts. However, the restrictions on shareholder eligibility and the inability to have other corporations as shareholders can limit an S-corp’s ability to raise capital compared to a C-corp.

Limited Liability Company (LLC)

A Limited Liability Company (LLC) combines the limited liability protection of a corporation with the flexibility of a partnership. LLCs are pass-through entities, so profits and taxes are passed directly to the owners, avoiding double taxation. This structure allows owners to manage the business directly or appoint managers, offering versatility in ownership and control.

LLCs protect owners’ personal assets from business debts and legal actions, providing limited liability similar to that of a corporation. Additionally, LLCs face fewer legal formalities and record-keeping requirements, making them an attractive option for small to medium-sized businesses seeking simplicity and protection.

Nonprofit corporation

A Nonprofit corporation is established to pursue cultural, literary, scientific, political, educational, or religious missions rather than to generate profits. Nonprofits can apply for 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status, exempting them from federal and state taxes on income related to their mission. While nonprofit corporations can generate profits, they are prohibited from distributing profits to their directors, officers, or members. Instead, any profits must be reinvested into the organization to further its mission.

This structure allows nonprofits to raise capital through donations, grants, and fundraising activities, providing limited liability protection to owners and shareholders. However, maintaining tax-exempt status requires strict adherence to legal guidelines and reporting requirements, ensuring that the organization remains focused on its mission.

B Corporation (Benefit Corporation)

A B Corporation (B-corp), also known as a Benefit Corporation, is a for-profit business committed to creating a positive impact on society and the environment. B-corps undergo rigorous assessments to demonstrate their dedication to social and environmental goals, achieving certification by meeting high standards of transparency, accountability, and performance.

B-corps retain the legal protections of a C-corp or S-corp while integrating their mission into their corporate structure. This commitment can attract shareholders who are interested in both financial returns and social impact, raising capital from investors who prioritize sustainability and ethical practices. Additionally, B-corps must regularly report on their social and environmental performance, which helps maintain ongoing transparency and accountability.

By choosing a B-corp structure, businesses can differentiate themselves in the market, appeal to conscious consumers, and build a reputation for responsible business practices while enjoying the limited liability and legal protections inherent to the corporate form.

What are the advantages of a corporation?

Choosing to incorporate your business brings a multitude of corporation pros that can significantly enhance your enterprise's growth and stability. For entrepreneurs and business owners evaluating different business structures, understanding the advantages of a corporation is key—here are eight benefits that highlight why incorporating might be the right move for your business.

1. Limited liability protection

One of the foremost advantages of forming a corporation is limited liability protection. This means that shareholders’ personal assets are shielded from the corporation's debts and legal obligations. If the corporation faces financial difficulties or lawsuits, owners are not personally liable, ensuring that their personal assets like homes and savings remain secure. This protection is a significant factor in why many business owners choose to incorporate, as it minimizes their personal financial risk.

2. Access to capital

Incorporating your business opens up more opportunities for raising capital. Corporations can issue stocks, allowing shareholders to invest in the company and providing a straightforward method to attract investors. 

Whether through public offerings or private stock sales, the ability to sell shares of stock can help corporations secure the funds they need to expand or invest in research and other growth initiatives. Access to capital is often more robust for corporations compared to other business structures, making it easier for them to scale effectively.

3. Perpetual existence

Unlike other business entities, corporations enjoy perpetual existence, meaning they continue to operate regardless of changes in ownership or shareholders. 

In other words, this structured business entity outlives its founders and initial investors, providing continuity and stability. For investors and employees, an assurance of longevity can make corporations an attractive option, fostering trust and confidence in the company's future.

4. Transferable ownership

Transferring ownership in a corporation is relatively simple, due to the transferability of shares of stock. Shareholders can easily buy and sell stocks, which means changes in ownership for corporations are straightforward, without disrupting the corporate structure.

This gives corporations flexibility to facilitate quick entry and exit for investors and new shareholders. The articles of incorporation typically outline the procedures for transferring ownership, so the corporation’s transactions can be conducted smoothly and legally.

5. Tax benefits and deductions

Corporations often enjoy various tax benefits. Depending on the corporate structure, such as C-corps or S-corps, businesses can take advantage of different tax deductions and strategies to minimize their tax burden. For example, S-corps allow income to pass through to shareholders’ personal tax returns, avoiding double taxation. Additionally, corporations can offer tax-free benefits like pension plans and insurance, further reducing taxable income and increasing their overall profitability.

6. Enhanced credibility and public perception

Incorporating your business elevates its credibility and public perception. Corporations are often viewed as more stable and trustworthy compared to unincorporated business entities, which can attract investors, customers, and suppliers. The formal corporate structure demonstrates that the business adheres to regulatory standards and maintains legal compliance, which can help foster confidence among stakeholders and a better company reputation in the market.

7. Attracting high-quality employees

A corporation's formal business structure and stability can make it a more appealing employer for top talent. Corporations can offer competitive employee benefits packages, including stock options, which serve as a powerful incentive for attracting and retaining high-quality employees. The promise of ownership through shares of stock aligns employees’ interests with the company's success, promoting loyalty and long-term commitment. Additionally, the perpetual existence and limited liability of a corporation provide a secure and attractive work environment.

8. Legal protections and continuity

Operating as a corporation provides robust legal protections that safeguard both the business and its shareholders. As a separate legal entity, a corporation can enter into contracts, own assets, and engage in litigation independently of its owners. This separation ensures that the corporation maintains continuity even as shareholders change, supporting seamless leadership transitions and ownership transfers. The legal framework governing corporations also enforces accountability and adherence to regulations, promoting sustainable and responsible business practices.

What are the disadvantages of a corporation?

All those advantages aside, it’s also important to consider the corporation drawbacks that come with this business structure. Evaluating potential corporation cons will help you make a well-informed decision about whether incorporating your business is the right move. Below, find eight key disadvantages to keep in mind.

1. Complex and costly setup

Incorporating a business involves navigating a labyrinth of paperwork, planning, and financial investment. The process starts with filing the articles of incorporation with your state’s secretary of state, which is just the beginning. Establishing a corporation requires extensive documentation to outline the ownership and corporate structure; many business owners end up needing the help of a legal professional.

Compared to other business structures like sole proprietorships or partnerships, the initial setup costs for a corporation can be substantially higher due to state filing fees and attorney expenses. The complexity and expense can be a considerable barrier for many entrepreneurs considering incorporation.

2. Double taxation

One of the most significant corporation drawbacks is double taxation.

For example, C-corps are subject to taxation at both the entity level and the shareholders’ personal income tax returns. The corporation pays taxes on its income, and then shareholders pay taxes again on dividends they receive. This double layer of taxation can reduce the overall profitability of the business.

While forming an S-corp can mitigate this issue by allowing income to pass through to shareholders’ personal tax returns, not all corporations qualify, and failing to meet the necessary requirements can revert the corp back to C-corp status, reinstating the double taxation burden.

3. Extensive record-keeping and reporting requirements

Incorporating a business demands rigorous record-keeping and reporting practices. Corporations must maintain detailed records of all financial transactions, shareholder meetings, and board of directors decisions. These legal obligations are not only time-consuming but also require meticulous attention to ensure compliance with state and federal regulations.

Failure to adhere to recordkeeping obligations can result in penalties, loss of corporate status, or even legal action. Additionally, the extensive documentation process can divert valuable resources away from core business activities, posing a challenge for smaller corporations with limited administrative capacity.

4. Limited control for shareholders

While shareholders are the owners of a corporation, their influence over day-to-day operations is typically limited. Decision-making authority is vested in the board of directors and corporate executives, which can create a disconnect between shareholders and the management team.

Shareholders have the right to vote on major issues, but those with smaller ownership stakes may find their voices are less impactful. The separation between ownership and control can lead to conflicts of interest and reduce the shareholders’ ability to influence the strategic direction of the corporation.

5. Higher regulatory scrutiny

Corporations operate under a stringent regulatory framework that imposes higher levels of scrutiny compared to other business structures. Compliance with labor laws, environmental regulations, securities laws, and other industry-specific standards is mandatory.

Corporations—and their boards of directors—have to stay up-to-date on ongoing regulatory changes and make sure all aspects of their operations meet legal requirements. This heightened regulatory environment increases the administrative burden and the risk of non-compliance, which can result in hefty fines, legal disputes, and reputational damage.

6. Loss of personal tax benefits

Incorporating as a corporation can lead to the loss of certain personal tax benefits that are available to sole proprietorships and partnerships. Unlike these simpler business structures, corporations cannot directly pass business income to the owners’ personal tax returns without triggering corporate tax obligations.

This means that owners may miss out on tax deductions and credits that they could otherwise claim if operating as a sole proprietorship or partnership. Additionally, profits retained within the corporation are subject to corporate taxes, which can reduce the overall tax efficiency of the business.

7. Rigid structure and formalities

Corporations must adhere to a rigid structure and a series of formal corporate formalities to maintain their status. This includes creating and following bylaws, appointing a board of directors, holding annual shareholder meetings, and keeping detailed board minutes.

These requirements impose a level of bureaucracy that can be cumbersome for corporations, especially smaller ones. The need to comply with these formalities can slow down decision-making processes and reduce the corporation’s flexibility in responding to market changes or internal challenges.

8. Reduced privacy

Incorporating a business significantly reduces the level of privacy available to its owners. Corporations are required to disclose extensive information through annual reports, financial statements, and shareholder data, all of which become public records. This transparency is governed by regulations such as the Securities and Exchange Act, which mandates the disclosure of sensitive information to regulators, competitors, and the public.

For owners who prefer to keep their personal and business affairs private, this lack of confidentiality can be a considerable disadvantage, potentially exposing strategic and financial details to external parties.

Incorporating your business as a corporation brings a mix of benefits and challenges. While the corporation pros can drive growth and provide significant protections, the corporation cons and drawbacks require careful consideration. By understanding these potential disadvantages, entrepreneurs and business owners can make informed decisions about whether incorporating aligns with their long-term ownership goals and operational strategies.

Is a corporation the right structure for your business?

Deciding whether to incorporate your business requires a careful evaluation of the advantages and disadvantages of a corporation. This assessment helps determine if the advantages can propel your business toward its goals and if you can effectively manage the disadvantages given your capital resources and industry demands.

For small business owners with aspirations for growth, incorporating as a corporation can be an appealing choice. A corporation offers a structured business framework that supports scalability and attracts investors, albeit with more rigidity and higher costs compared to other business structures.

Step 1: Assess your business needs

Before making the decision to incorporate, consider the following factors:

• Growth potential: If your small business is poised for significant expansion and requires substantial capital to fuel growth, a corporation can facilitate the raising of capital through the sale of stocks.
• Liability protection: For owners seeking to protect their personal assets from business liabilities, the limited liability offered by a corporation is a major advantage.
• Attracting talent: If attracting and retaining high-quality employees is important for your business, the ability to offer stock options as part of compensation packages can be a significant benefit.
• Perpetual existence: If you want a business that can continue beyond the involvement of its founders, the perpetual existence of a corporation can offer you continuity and stability.

Step 2: Weigh the pros and cons

Evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of incorporating to see how they align with your business goals:

• Advantages: Enhanced credibility, access to capital, limited liability, and the ability to attract investors and top talent
• Disadvantages: Higher setup and maintenance costs, double taxation, extensive record-keeping and reporting requirements, and reduced privacy

Step 3: Consider the steps to incorporate your business

If you decide that a corporation is the right business structure for your needs, you can take advantage of one of these formation options:

• Create the structure yourself: Utilize online resources and state-provided forms to file your articles of incorporation and establish your corporate structure.
• Hire a lawyer: Engaging a legal professional ensures that all legal obligations are met and that your corporation is set up correctly according to state laws.
• Use a formation service: There are numerous services available that specialize in corporation formations, handling the paperwork and compliance aspects on your behalf.

When incorporating a business, you’ll need to adhere to specific formation requirements that vary by state. It is essential to stay informed about the latest rules and regulations to avoid delays or noncompliance issues. Consulting with an accountant and an attorney can provide valuable guidance, so your corporation remains in good standing and operates efficiently.

Ultimately, the decision to incorporate hinges on whether the advantages align with your business objectives and if you are prepared to manage the disadvantages. For many small businesses, the benefits of limited liability, access to capital, and enhanced credibility outweigh the challenges, making a corporation a compelling type of business structure to consider.

Kick off your business on the right foot with Rippling

Launching a startup or new business involves juggling numerous tasks, from managing HR processes to handling finance operations.

Rippling lets you offload critical admin work for payroll, benefits, compliance, IT, and finance, helping your business grow fast and stay lean. Do more with less, like offering access to world-class benefits and reliable payroll that can be managed in one place, plus manage apps and devices, hiring and paying international employees, expense management, compliance support, and more.

This blog is based on information available to Rippling as of December 4, 2024.

Disclaimer: Rippling and its affiliates do not provide tax, accounting, or legal advice. This material has been prepared for informational purposes only, and is not intended to provide or be relied on for tax, accounting, or legal advice. You should consult your own tax, accounting, and legal advisors before engaging in any related activities or transactions.